What Prison Will I Be Sent To? Why Federal Prison Placement Starts Before Sentencing

5–8 minutes

read

One of the most common questions federal criminal defendants ask their lawyers is, “What prison will I be sent to?” Too often, the answer is simply, “That’s up to the Bureau of Prisons.”

Technically, that is correct. Under 18 U.S.C. § 3621(b), the Bureau of Prisons has the authority to designate the place of a federal prisoner’s imprisonment. The sentencing judge does not decide where the person will serve the sentence, and a recommendation from the court is not binding on the BOP.

But that is not the whole story. Section 3621(b) also lays out the factors the BOP must consider when deciding where to place someone. Those include bed availability, the prisoner’s security classification, programmatic needs, mental and medical health needs, the nature and circumstances of the offense, the prisoner’s history and characteristics, and the resources of the facility being considered.

And critically, 18 U.S.C. § 3621(b)(4)(B) expressly directs the BOP to consider any recommendation by the sentencing court concerning the type of penal or correctional facility that would be appropriate.

That matters. The judge does not control placement, but the judge’s recommendation is not some informal suggestion that the BOP can simply pretend does not exist. Congress specifically included the sentencing court’s recommendation among the factors the BOP is supposed to consider when making a designation decision.

That creates an important opportunity for defense counsel before sentencing.

How the BOP Decides Where Someone Goes

Federal prison designations are handled through the Bureau of Prisons’ Designation and Sentence Computation Center, commonly called the DSCC. The DSCC reviews the sentencing materials and determines what institution is appropriate for the person.

This is not simply a matter of finding the nearest prison with an open bed. The BOP evaluates the offense, criminal history, sentence length, security level, medical needs, mental-health needs, programming needs, release residence, separation issues, and other security concerns.

The BOP also considers characteristics that may make someone more vulnerable in the prison population. Age, physical build, prior incarceration experience, and other factors can affect whether someone is likely to be victimized or have difficulty functioning safely in a particular environment.

For people convicted of sex offenses, another major consideration is whether placement at a Sex Offender Management Program, or SOMP, institution is appropriate.

SOMP institutions are federal prisons designated to manage significant populations of people with sex-offense histories. Because many people at those institutions have similar offense backgrounds, the environment is generally better suited to managing that population. Specialized programming may also be available.

A sex offense often points toward placement at a SOMP institution, but it does not guarantee it. People do sometimes end up at prisons that are a poor fit for their offense or vulnerabilities. Sometimes they manage. Sometimes they do not.

The Closest Prison May Be the Wrong Prison

Section 3621(b) also directs the BOP, when practicable and subject to the other statutory considerations, to place a person as close as possible to their primary residence and, to the extent practicable, within 500 driving miles.

That is a reasonable goal. Family visitation matters. Staying connected to spouses, children, parents, and other loved ones can make a major difference during a prison sentence.

But there is a problem. The prison closest to someone’s home may not be the prison that is safest or most appropriate for that person.

That is particularly important in sex-offense cases. There are only a limited number of SOMP institutions in the federal system. Depending on where someone lives, the appropriate SOMP facility may be hundreds of miles away from home.

That creates a tradeoff, but it is an important one to understand before sentencing.

Having to drive or fly farther to visit someone in prison is difficult. Having that person spend years in an institution where the offense makes them a target can be far worse.

The question should not simply be, “What prison is closest to his family?”

The better question may be, “What prison gives this person the best chance of safely serving the sentence?” Those are not always the same place.

This Is Where the Defense Lawyer Can Make a Difference

Because § 3621(b)(4)(B) specifically requires the BOP to consider the sentencing court’s recommendation, defense counsel should think carefully about what recommendation to ask the judge to make.

In an appropriate sex-offense case, simply requesting placement “as close to home as possible” may not be enough. Counsel should consider asking the judge to recommend placement at a SOMP institution.

It may also make sense to identify several SOMP facilities that are consistent with the defendant’s anticipated security level, medical needs, sentence length, programming needs, and other circumstances.

That gives the BOP options while still making the court’s intent clear.

The request can also explain why a SOMP placement is appropriate. The issue is not preferential treatment. It is safety, proper classification, and placement in an institution designed to manage people with that offense history.

The BOP still makes the final decision. Bed space, security level, medical issues, population concerns, and other factors may prevent placement at the exact facility requested.

But a thoughtful recommendation from the sentencing judge can be a significant part of the designation process, and federal law expressly says the BOP is supposed to consider it.

Getting the Wrong Prison the First Time Can Be Brutal

Getting the designation right the first time matters because fixing a bad placement can take a long time.

If someone arrives at a prison where they cannot safely remain in the general population, they may end up in protective custody or restrictive housing while the institution decides what to do next.

If the BOP ultimately determines that the person needs to be redesignated and transferred, the process can take weeks or months.

During that time, the person may spend most of the day locked in a cell with severely limited access to normal prison life. Email access may disappear. Phone access may be severely restricted. Programming, recreation, work assignments, and ordinary movement may all be limited.

In practical terms, the person can end up sitting in a concrete box waiting for the BOP to move them to a safer prison.

That is a terrible way to begin a federal prison sentence.

And in some cases, better planning before sentencing may have reduced the likelihood of it happening at all.

Prison Placement Should Be Part of Sentencing Strategy

Defense lawyers spend enormous amounts of time arguing over how many months their clients will serve. They should also spend some time thinking about where those months or years will actually be served.

For a person with a sex offense, that means evaluating whether a SOMP institution is appropriate and, when it is, asking the sentencing judge for a specific and well-supported recommendation.

Yes, 18 U.S.C. § 3621(b) gives the Bureau of Prisons the authority to decide where a federal prisoner will be housed.

But the same statute also tells the BOP what it must consider. And under § 3621(b)(4)(B), one of those things is the sentencing court’s recommendation about the type of facility that is appropriate.

So when a lawyer tells a client, “It’s up to the BOP,” that is only part of the answer. The better answer is this: The BOP makes the final placement decision based on many factors, but a recommendation from the sentencing judge can go a long way toward helping you get to the right prison the first time.

If you need some guidance on how to request this recommendation, I can offer some insight into what has worked in other cases I’ve been involved in.

Dale Chappell prepares people in sensitive, high-profile, and high-stakes federal cases for prison. He works with clients, families, and attorneys during pretrial, throughout incarceration, and during the transition to halfway house placement, home confinement, and supervised release.

Dale brings more than 17 years of experience, firsthand knowledge of the federal prison system, and experience testifying at high-profile public hearings on prison and criminal justice issues. He helps clients protect their safety and privacy, avoid decisions that can follow them throughout their sentences, and prepare for the strongest possible outcome at every stage.

Dale has written nearly 600 published articles on federal prison, post-conviction, and criminal justice issues.

Have questions?
Contact Dale directly at dale@facingfederalprison.com.

Leave a Reply