Lately, I’ve had some people ask if I use AI to do law work, as if using AI in any way automatically makes the work unreliable. I understand why some might think that: AI has developed a bad reputation because too many people use it irresponsibly. But when it’s used correctly, it’s one of the most valuable tools available to professionals in any field, including law.
AI-assisted work is not the same as AI-drafted work. AI-assisted doesn’t mean blindly letting a computer write legal arguments. It means using verified, legal-specific tools to refine and strengthen what a human expert has already researched, analyzed, and written.
Because of recent news stories about law firms improperly relying on AI in court filings, it’s important to clarify what AI-assisted legal work actually means, and how it can be used responsibly to maintain the highest standards of accuracy and quality.
When applied properly, AI doesn’t replace knowledge or experience; it helps ensure that both are communicated clearly and accurately. In professional legal writing, AI is used to refine and validate the research, structure, and language that a qualified expert develops. In other words, it helps ensure that depth of experience and understanding is reflected in the clarity, precision, and professionalism of the final product.
AI-Assisted Means Human-Led, Not Computer-Generated
AI has gotten a bad name in the legal field, and not because of the technology itself, but because of how it’s being used. Too many attorneys are submitting work that was drafted by generic AI tools without verifying a single citation or quote. The result is predictable: motions filled with erroneous citations, fabricated quotes, and entire passages of made-up law. Every example I’ve seen of AI work criticized by a court comes down to the same failure: the human never checked the output.
Some argue that AI is fine to use as long as the person verifies the cites and quotes afterward. But that misses the deeper issue. The quality of what AI produces depends entirely on the person guiding it. Without the right legal knowledge, judgment, and experience, AI will never deliver accurate or persuasive results, no matter how much fact-checking happens after the fact.
That’s the difference between AI-generated and AI-assisted work.
- AI-generated means a chatbot writes content on its own. That’s reckless and unprofessional.
- AI-assisted means an experienced human conducts the research, analysis, and drafting, then uses professional-grade AI software to refine the work.
AI-assisted tools can check formatting, consistency, grammar, and tone, and they help transform a well-researched argument into a polished, compelling motion. But the judgment, reasoning, and strategy still come entirely from the human leading the process.
A Real Example
A law firm recently asked me to take a set of arguments they had written and properly format them into a § 2255 motion ready to be filed in court. They hadn’t drafted the motion itself, just the argument sections, and asked me to handle the structure and presentation.
Even though my task was only to format it, I always review and verify everything I’m given. Accuracy matters too much in this field. I’d rather prevent problems than spend time fixing them later.
When I started checking the work, I found that nearly every citation and quote was wrong. It was immediately clear that an AI chatbot had generated the content. What was supposed to be a few hours of formatting turned into several days of research and rewriting the arguments entirely from scratch.
The firm was shocked to learn how unreliable those public AI services can be. Generic AI chat tools simply aren’t built for legal accuracy; they make up cases, misquote opinions, and distort precedent.
Did I use AI to finalize the § 2255 motion for that firm? Of course, but only for what it does best: ensuring clean grammar, consistent tone, and the persuasive style the firm wanted. AI is excellent for polishing language; the substance still comes from human expertise, research, and judgment.
How I Use Legal AI Tools in My Work
After I research case law, develop the strategy, and write the arguments for the firm, I use AI in the same way that major law firms and federal defender offices do: as a quality-control and refinement tool.
Here’s what that looks like in real-world practice:
- Verification of Every Citation and Quote.
I run each citation and quotation through Lexis. Even though I provide the citations and quotes in the argument, I still verify that the AI tool didn’t change anything. If something doesn’t match exactly, I go back to the original source and correct it. - Improving Clarity and Readability.
Legal arguments can get dense fast. AI helps me test whether a paragraph is too long, whether a point could be expressed more directly, or whether the flow would make sense to a reader unfamiliar with the record. I once used the tool to simplify a complex ineffective-assistance claim involving multiple sub-issues. The content stayed the same, but the AI tool suggested a reorganization that made the sequence of arguments easier to follow, the kind of improvement that wins attention from a busy judge. - Refining Tone and Flow.
The way a motion sounds can influence how it’s received. I use AI to ensure that the writing has a professional, confident tone, firm but respectful, and that it stays consistent throughout. It can also analyze rhythm and word balance, helping transform a solid draft into a smooth, persuasive final version. - Finding Inconsistencies or Weak Transitions.
When I’m deep into a 40-page motion, it’s easy to overlook small disconnects between sections. AI can flag when two points overlap or when a transition between claims feels abrupt. For instance, in one case, the AI tool pointed out that a paragraph repeated language from an earlier section almost word-for-word. I rewrote it for variety and flow, strengthening the overall argument.
Every project goes through this process before it’s finalized and reviewed by a licensed attorney. That’s what separates professional, verified AI use from the careless shortcuts that have given the technology a bad name.
The Bottom Line
AI isn’t a shortcut, but a quality-control system, like using Lexis, Westlaw, or Grammarly. The difference is that legal AI tools allow someone to apply the same level of precision and consistency that large law firms rely on.
When used responsibly, AI improves both accuracy and presentation. It helps ensure that citations are correct, arguments flow logically, and the final document reads with the tone and professionalism that federal courts expect. When used carelessly, however, AI can do real harm, producing false citations, misquoting law, or creating the illusion of expertise where none exists.
Everything I produce remains the result of research, experience, and judgment built over 16 years of work in federal court. The technology simply helps me present that work at the highest standard possible. It’s a tool, not a replacement.
That’s why I’m sharing this with everyone now: to set the record straight, to clarify the role of AI in professional legal work, and to reaffirm what has always defined my approach: integrity, accuracy, and trust. The legal field is evolving, and I’m committed to leading that change responsibly.

Dale Chappell prepares people in sensitive, high-profile, and high-stakes federal cases for prison. He works with clients, families, and attorneys during pretrial, throughout incarceration, and during the transition to halfway house placement, home confinement, and supervised release.
Dale brings more than 17 years of experience, firsthand knowledge of the federal prison system, and experience testifying at high-profile public hearings on prison and criminal justice issues. He helps clients protect their safety and privacy, avoid decisions that can follow them throughout their sentences, and prepare for the strongest possible outcome at every stage.
Dale has written nearly 600 published articles on federal prison, post-conviction, and criminal justice issues.
Have questions?
Contact Dale directly at dale@facingfederalprison.com.


Leave a Reply