Why Every Federal Child Pornography Case Will Now Be at the Top of the Sentencing Guidelines Range

2–4 minutes

read

In child pornography cases, sentencing is influenced by the number of “images” involved in the offense, as mandated by the U.S. Sentencing Guidelines under U.S.S.G. § 2G2.2(b)(7). This guideline establishes a graduated sentencing enhancement based on the number of images. While this is straightforward for still images, it becomes complicated with videos. Traditionally, the guideline commentary equated each video to 75 images, regardless of length. However, this approach was recently challenged and overturned, significantly influenced by the Supreme Court’s decision in Kisor v. Wilkie.

In United States v. Haggerty, No. 23-2084, 2024 U.S. App. LEXIS 16634 (3d Cir. July 9, 2024), Robert Haggerty, a 62-year-old first-time offender, was indicted in February 2022 for receiving and possessing visual depictions of minors engaged in sexually explicit conduct. The investigation revealed 97 still images and 9 videos depicting child sexual abuse.

At sentencing, the district court applied a five-level enhancement under § 2G2.2(b)(7), treating each video as 75 images based on the commentary. Haggerty challenged this, arguing that under Kisor v. Wilkie, the guideline’s plain text does not support treating a video as 75 images. He suggested that either each video should count as one image or each frame should count as a separate image.

The Sentencing Dilemma: Videos vs. Still Images

The sentencing enhancement process is clear when dealing with still images. But how should videos be treated? The guideline itself does not specify, leading judges to rely on the commentary, which states that each video constitutes 75 images. This interpretation has now been deemed incorrect.

The Impact of Kisor v. Wilkie

Kisor v. Wilkie, 588 U.S. 558, 139 S. Ct. 2400 (2019) fundamentally changed how courts should interpret administrative guidelines. The Supreme Court ruled that courts should defer to an agency’s interpretation only if the regulation is genuinely ambiguous after using all traditional tools of construction.

Applying Kisor to Haggerty’s case, the appellate court examined whether the term “image” was genuinely ambiguous when applied to videos. The court concluded that it was not. They determined that “image,” in the context of a video, unambiguously means “frame.” Thus, the court ruled that deference to the commentary’s 75-images-per-video rule was unwarranted.

The court’s reasoning included several key points:

  • 1. Plain Text and Ordinary Meaning: The term “image” typically refers to a still visual representation. In the context of videos, each frame is considered a separate image.
  • 2. Dictionary Definitions: Contemporary and historical dictionary definitions supported interpreting “image” as a still representation, not inclusive of videos.
  • 3. Guideline Structure and Purpose: The structure and purpose of § 2G2.2(b)(7) support counting each frame as an individual image, aligning with the guideline’s intent to proportionately increase penalties based on the amount of child pornography.

By treating each frame as an individual image, the number of “images” involved in a case can increase dramatically, potentially leading to harsher sentences. However, this approach ensures sentences reflect the volume of abusive content accurately.

The court vacated the district court’s sentencing order and remanded the case for resentencing, directing that the number of frames in the videos be counted to determine the appropriate enhancement under § 2G2.2(b)(7). This approach aligns with the plain meaning of “image” and the guideline’s purpose.

The ruling in Haggerty’s case, influenced by Kisor v. Wilkie, marks a pivotal shift in interpreting sentencing guidelines for child pornography offenses involving videos. By clarifying that “image” means “frame,” the court ensured that nearly every child pornography case would score at the top of the guideline range.

Leave a Reply